Who Sings It Better?

Going back to a classic song today, our match up will be two versions of "Your Song" by Elton John.

First up, Elton John.

Next up, the version of Your Song from the movie Moulin Rouge.

So, which do I prefer?  Not an easy choice at all.  I've heard this song on the radio throughout my life, but the first time I heard the song on Moulin Rouge I hardly recognized it.  I loved how they completely changed the melody, and Ewan McGregor is such a sweetheart while he sings it! 

This round goes to.....Ewan McGregor; but only because he sang new life into the song for me.

So, who sings it better?